SEED Guides Selecting Manufacturing Processes < >

7. Concluding Remarks

The need to provide the concept design and development stages of the product introduction process with carefully structured knowledge about process characteristics and capabilities has been highlighted.

PRocess Information MAps (PRIMAs) to a standard form and similar level of detail for a sample set of manufacturing processes have been presented. A simple method based on material and production quantity was designed to enable a user to focus attention on the most relevant PRIMAs. The application of the data provided in the PRIMAs as a means of selecting candidate manufacturing processes has been illustrated.

Injection moulding [2,1]

Economic Considerations

  • Production rates are high, cycle times of 10 to 6O seconds typical.
  • Lead times can be several weeks duo to manufacturing of complex dies.
  • Economical for high production runs - typically 10,000+.
  • Tooling costs are high. Dies are usually made from tool steel,
  • Equipment costs are moderate to high.
  • Direct labour costs are low.
  • Finishing costs are low - little trimming required.

Typical Applications

  • Containers.
  • Bottle tops.
  • Housings.

Design Aspects

  • Very complex shapes and intricate detail possible.
  • Pockets, holes, bosses and minor re-entrant features common.
  • Uniform section thickness should be maintained.
  • Maximum section, typically = 13mm.
  • Minimum section = 0.4mm for thermoplastics.
  • Sizes range from 10g to 25kg in weight for thermoplastics, 6kg maximum for thermosets.

Vacuum forming [2.3]

Economic Considerations

  • Process cycle times range from 10 to 60 seconds.
  • Set-up times and change-over times are low.
  • Production volume trends vary from small batches (10) to high volume, 1,000+.
  • Tooling costs are low to moderate, depending on complexity.
  • Equipment costs are low to moderate, but can be high it automated.
  • Labour costs are low to moderate.
  • Finishing costs are low.

Typical Applications

  • Open plastic containers.
  • Electronic enclosures.
  • Bath tubs.

Design Aspects

  • Shape complexity limited to mouldings in one plane.
  • Open forms of constant thickness without re-entrant angles.
  • Maximum section 3mm.
  • Minimum section = 0.05mm to 0.5mm, depending on material used.
  • Sizes range from 25mm2 to 7.5m x 2.5m in area.

Compression moulding [2.2]

Economic Considerations

  • Production cycle times from 20 to 600 seconds typical.
  • Production volumes are typically 1,000+, but can be as low as 100 for large parts.
  • Tooling costs are generally high.
  • Equipment costs are moderate to high.
  • Direct labour and finishing costs are generally low. Flash removal required.

Typical Applications

  • Dishes.
  • Container caps.

Design Aspects

  • Shape complexity is limited to relatively simple forms. Moulding in one plane only.
  • Holes, protrusions, pockets and minor to entrant features are possible.
  • Maximum section, typically = 25mm.
  • Minimum section = 0.25mm.
  • Sizes range from several grammes to 15kg in weight.

Blow Moulding [2.4]

Economic Considerations

  • Production rates between 100 and 2,500 pieces/hour, depending on size.
  • Production volumes of up to 10,000,000, but also suitable for quantities as low as 1,000.
  • Tooling costs are moderate to high.
  • Equipment costs are moderate to high.
  • Direct labour costs are low, one operator can manage several machines.
  • Finishing cots are low: trimming only.

Typical Applications

  • Hollow plastic parts with relatively thin walls.
  • Bottles.

Design Aspects

  • Complexity limited to hollow, well rounded, thin walled parts with low degree of asymmetry.
  • Threads, inserts and undercuts all possible.
  • Holes cannot be moulded.
  • Maximum section = 6mm. Thick sections may need cooling aids (carbon dioxide or nitrogen).
  • Minimum section 0.25mm.
  • Sizes range from 12mm in length to volumes up to 3m3.

Figure 7 Comparison of PRIMA data